TIL those cheap silicone baking mats from the dollar bin melt at 400 degrees and ruined my sheet pan
I grabbed a 2 pack for $3 at the Dollar Tree on Main last month thinking I scored. First batch of cookies at 375 was fine, but when I cranked the oven to 425 for roasted veggies, the mat curled up and left a sticky gray film fused to my pan. I scrubbed for 40 minutes with Bar Keepers Friend and it still looks awful, so that's $3 gone plus a $25 sheet pan. The label said oven safe but the fine print said up to 350, which I never read. Has anyone found a cheap mat that actually holds up to high heat, or do I just need to spend the money on a real one?
Nothing says "dollar store bargain" quite like a baking mat that turns into modern art on your sheet pan. At least you got a science lesson and a permanent reminder of your $28 mistake. Buy the real Silpat next time, it costs more up front but it won't fuse itself to your cookware.