Serious question, stick welding roots or TIG roots on 6 inch schedule 40?
Got into it with a guy on the crew at the Whiting turnaround about our root pass on 6 inch schedule 40 and I want some honest input. I've always run a 6010 root and backed it with hot pass, but he swears a TIG root saves us a full repair pass because it comes out cleaner on the inside. We cut two test pieces open on his side and mine, and his had way less slag trapped in the joint, no arguing that. I still think 6010 is faster on the ground and a guy can fix a keyhole without shutting down. So which one are you running on carbon pipe that size, and what actually made the difference for you?