Had to choose between a bigger bucket or a thumb for the old excavator
My boss gave me a choice last spring, either get a new 36-inch bucket for the 320 or add a mechanical thumb to the 24-inch one we had. I went with the thumb, thinking it would be more useful for the demo work we had lined up. It cost about $2,500 to install, but it let me pick up and place concrete chunks way easier than just pushing them into a pile. After three months on a site clearing old foundations, I was moving material almost twice as fast. Anyone else had to make a call like that on a machine attachment?
You spent only $2,500 on that thumb install? That seems way too low for a full mechanical thumb setup on a 320. I had a quote last year that was almost double that for the parts and labor. Did you do the welding yourself or find some crazy deal?
Actually have to disagree on that one. The thumb is doing the real heavy lifting here, not the back. That's a repetitive stress injury waiting to happen. Seen it too many times. You trade one kind of strain for another, and wrist or thumb problems can be just as bad.
But you're missing the whole point of using a tool. The thumb drive lets you move a huge amount of data without touching a single box. That's the win. A sore thumb for a day beats a wrecked back for life, every single time. You can always switch hands or take a break, but a back injury sticks with you. It's not a perfect trade, but it's a way better one.