Pro tip: My neighbor told me I was choking my brisket with too much smoke
I used to load up my offset with wood chunks every half hour, thinking more smoke meant more flavor. Last month my neighbor Steve, who's won 3 local comps in Austin, watched me cook and said I was basically suffocating the meat. He told me to only add wood when the fire needs it, not on a timer, and my last brisket actually had clean smoke ring instead of that bitter tar taste. Anyone else learn that lesson the hard way or was I just being a bonehead?
Beats me why we all think drowning meat in smoke is the way to go until some guy named Steve shows up and sets us straight. I mean, my first few briskets tasted like I was licking the bottom of a fire pit, and I just assumed that was how it was supposed to be. Guess we gotta learn somehow, even if it means eating ash for a while.
Oh man, that comment about Steve cracked me up. My buddy Dan went through the exact same thing last summer. He was so proud of his first brisket, brought it to a cookout and we were all just choking down this bitter, ashy mess trying to be polite. Turns out he was using like a whole bag of wood chips every hour because he thought more smoke meant more flavor. It took him three tries and a talk with some old timer at the hardware store to figure out he was basically cremating the meat.