4
That time a reviewer told me my lesson plans were too rigid
I teach 7th grade history in Denver and a parent feedback form last year said my class felt like a checklist, not a discussion. I switched to letting kids pick topics from a list for 15 minutes each Friday and engagement went up by like 40 percent. But now I worry I'm losing structure and kids miss key dates. Has anyone else found a good middle ground between flexibility and covering the standards?
4 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In4 Comments
carr.abby12d ago
Read a study recently that said students remember more when they have some control over what they learn, but they still need a clear framework to connect it all together. Maybe keep your Friday choice time but use Monday through Thursday to hit the required dates and concepts. A teacher friend of mine does something similar with her middle schoolers and she maps out the whole year's standards first, then builds in two flexible days a month for student-led topics.
3
eva_moore11d ago
Agree with @carr.abby on this, it's basically how my favorite local coffee shop works - they let you customize your drink but the syrup flavors are still organized by a little chart on the wall. That mix of structure and freedom just clicks for people.
5
olivia_white9311d ago
Wait, hold on - a chart on the wall? That's actually wild to me. I mean, I get the idea of having some structure, but organizing syrup flavors by a chart feels like it would take all the fun out of ordering. Like, half the joy of going to a coffee shop is just staring at the menu and picking something random that sounds good. Having a chart makes it feel like a math problem or something. Does it really work better than just listing them out like normal? I feel like people would just look at the chart and default to the first one they see.
1
kimw578d ago
Tried this with my kids' homework routine and it worked perfectly. Gave them a list of topics they HAD to learn but let them pick the order each week. The structure kept them from getting overwhelmed but the choices kept them engaged.
1